|
How to Contact Us
Services
Dr. Lowe
Offers
Patients
Evaluation
Forms
How to Prepare
for Your Metabolic Evaluation
How to Submit Questions
General
Information
News
Archived
E-mail Newsletters
Publications
Patient-to-Patient
Jackie Yellin
About Dr. Lowe
Fibromyalgia Research
Foundation
In Memoriam
Links to
Other Websites
Myofascial Pain
Nutrition
Testimonials

The Metabolic Treatment
of Fibromyalgia
by Dr. John C. Lowe
Readers' Comments
|
|
June
23, 1999
Larry Updike interviewed
Dr. John C. Lowe on
CJOB radio (Manitoba, Canada)
Larry Updike interviewed Dr. John C. Lowe on CJOB radio,
Winnipeg,
Canada, on Monday, June 28, 1999, 2-3 PM. Larry and Dr. Lowe discussed the regulation of
the thyroid gland and some problems within conventional medicine with the diagnosis and
treatment of thyroid dysfunction. Dr. Lowe also answered questions from callers. Because
of the fast-paced nature of the program, however, Dr. Lowe was not able to cover a number
of important issues. Information on these issues is critical for improving the care of
patients with hypothyroidism and/or thyroid hormone resistance. Patients in Manitoba are
in particular need of this information. To provide the information not covered during the
interview, we will publish here Dr. Lowe's summary. We hope to have this most important
information posted here soon. Please check back. (Dr. Lowe extends his thanks to Larry
Updike for providing air time, and to Manitoba health activist and medical critic Susan
Caine for helping arrange the interview.)
Original
Post: June 12, 1999
The Licensed Dietitian
Act--
A Letter from Dr. John C. Lowe to
Texas Governor George W. Bush

On June 8, 1999, Mart Whittekin, a health
liberties activist with Texans for Health Freedom,
e-mailed Dr. John C. Lowe. She explained that Governor George W. Bush had a bill on his
desk that had been slipped past in the closing moments of the Texas Legislature. She
explained that the Governor had 20 days to either sign the bill or veto it. Senate Bill
1525 would give licensed dietitians a virtual monopoly on professional services related to
diet and nutrition. Health care practitioners licensed in Texas, such as MDs, DCs,
D.O.s, DDSs, and nurses, would be exempt. (Mart correctly pointed out, "Of those exempted,
only chiropractors usually have any nutrition training.") However, practitioners for
whom there was no licensing would, with passage of the bill, be prohibited from charging a
fee for dietary and nutritional counseling and therapy. Who would be excluded? Clinical
nutritionists, naturopaths, non-MD homeopaths, PhD nutrition counselors, and many other
professionals. Passage of the bill would deny these practitioners an income from their
professional services. As Martie explained, these professionals "will be either
criminals or unemployed unless Governor Bush vetoes the Act."
Martie was correct. A copy of Senate Bill 1525 was posted at "Texas Legislature
Online." Section 3(c) of the proposed Act stipulated: "Unless the person is
licensed under this Act, a person may not for compensation provide nutrition services or
hold that person out as authorized by law to provide nutrition services." According
to Section 3(d), violation of the law would be a Class B misdemeanor. Section 15A(a) read:
"In this Section, 'giving advice concerning nutrition' or 'providing nutritional
advice' means giving information on the use and role of food and food ingredients,
including dietary supplements."
After communicating with Martie, Dr. Lowe promptly wrote and sent a letter to Governor
Bush. In it, he requested that the Governor veto SB1525. Read Dr.
Lowe's full letter to the Governor.
We posted a request here for concerned
citizens to contact the Governor's office before June 20th, 1999. By asking him to veto
the bill, citizens would help ensure citizens' rights and freedom of choice in health care
professionals.
In another e-mail dated June 12, 1999, Martie wrote: "Activists in Austin are meeting
to protest SB1525. They will be on the Capitol steps at 10AM on Monday June 14. How
appropriate. That is flag day and we are standing up for our rights that the flag
represents. Please spread the word to anyone you know in Austin."
Updated
Post: June 21, 1999
Outcome
The efforts of many people to influence the
Governor's decision paid off--he vetoed the bill. In an e-mail send out by Martie
Whittekin on June 21, 1999, she wrote: "History tells us that only massive pressure
from citizens could have created the motivation and comfort level for the Governor to go
against the nearly unanimous action of the legislature. He stood up for the people against
the big money special interests. A call or fax to give him an 'attaboy' might help him
understand that we will still be watching should he become President." We praise
Martie for the time and effort she invested to successfully rally opposition to
SB1525.
March
11, 1999
Two Patients Take Conventional
Endocrinology to Task
Physicist John
Ziman wrote an excellent book on the grounds for belief in science. In it, he said:
"The experts in a particular field can become so indoctrinated and so committed to
the current paradigm that their critical and imaginative powers are inhibited, and they
cannot 'see beyond their own noses.'" When the experts can no longer see beyond
their noses, the public has grounds for not believing in their science. In recent years,
steadily growing numbers of people have expressed the belief that the experts in
conventional endocrinology can't "see beyond their noses." Why do people express
this belief about the experts? Mainly for one reason: The experts' beliefs about thyroid
hormone treatment keep many people sick. And these people remain sick until they undergo
treatment by practitioners who don't share the experts' beliefs. Obviously, the
expert's beliefs are wrong. Yet despite the continuing illness of patients and their
subsequent recovery under the care of other practitioners, the experts hold tenaciously to
their false beliefs. It is little wonder then that patients question the credibility
of conventional endocrinology "experts."
Professor Ziman also wrote, "In these circumstances, scientific progress may come to
a halt--knowledge may even regress--until intellectual intruders come through the
interdisciplinary frontiers and look at the field without preconceptions."
Scientific progress in the treatment of hypothyroid patients has regressed. Before the
early 1970s, most hypothyroid patients were satisfied with the safe and effective
treatment doctors provided. But in the early 70s, the TSH and other modern thyroid tests
came into widespread use. With the advent of these tests, endocrinologists agreed among
themselves to permit patients to take only half the dosage of thyroid hormone previously
used. In addition, one powerful pharmaceutical company purchased the allegiance of
conventional endocrinology. In accord with the implicit financial deal, conventional
endocrinology used its authority for the good of the company. The "experts"
influenced patients and their doctors to believe that the only legitimate thyroid product
to use was that company's brand--a brand we now know often provides patients with inferior
treatment results.
In recent years, out of this sorry state of affairs, examples of the "intellectual
intruders" Ziman referred to have come forth. Some of these "intruders" are
doctors outside the endocrinology fraternity. They are dedicated foremost to the welfare
of patients, and they couldn't care less for the affluence and prestige derived through
allegiance to the interests of powerful pharmaceutical companies.
Also among the "intellectual intruders" are some patients forsaken by
conventional endocrinology. The beliefs of the experts in conventional endocrinology are
partly a product of financial manipulations by pharmaceutical companies. But the beliefs
of these intruding patients are a product of personal experience with the miseries caused
by the beliefs of the endocrinology experts. These intruding patients are the salvation of
other patients who have remained ill because of the beliefs of the experts.
Recently, two such patients, Mary Shomon in the US and Karen Goodfellow in England, have
publicly spoken out. These "intruders," with intelligence and eloquence, have
taken conventional endocrinology to task. In that most patients' fibromyalgia is a product
of too little thyroid hormone regulation of tissues, I urge fibromyalgia patients to read
what Mary and Karen have written. I also recommend that physicians--especially
endocrinologists--read with an open mind what these two patients have to say. Their views
may help melt away the cognitive shackles buckled into place by vested corporate interests
through conventional medical education. ---Dr. John C. Lowe
Reference
John Ziman: "Reliable Knowledge: An Exploration of
the Grounds for Beliefs in Science." Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 1978.
Mary Shomon
(Mary Shomon is an author and producer of
the popular and award winning thyroid disease
Web site and the newsletter Sticking Out Our Necks)
Karen Goodfellow
(Karen Goodfellow is Research and Development
Officer of the International Thyroid Group in England.)
|