Fibromyalgia, Hypothyroidism, Thyroid Hormone Resistance

General Information
Homepage

What We Know About Fibromyalgia | Overview of Fibromyalgia
"But That's Only a Theory!" |
Links to Helpful Information
What Our Research Has Really Shown
| Testimonials
Do You Have Symptoms of Hypothyroidism or Thyroid Hormone Resistance?

Do You Have Signs of Hypothyroidism or Thyroid Hormone Resistance?

dot_clear.gif (54 bytes)

How to Contact Us

Services Dr. Lowe
Offers Patients

Evaluation Forms

How to Prepare
for Your Metabolic Evaluation

How to Submit Questions

General Information

News

Archived E-mail Newsletters

Publications

Patient-to-Patient
Jackie Yellin

About Dr. Lowe

Fibromyalgia Research Foundation

In Memoriam

Links to Other Websites

Myofascial Pain

Nutrition

Testimonials

bookcovr.jpg (3834 bytes)

The Metabolic Treatment
of Fibromyalgia

by Dr. John C. Lowe
Readers' Comments

 

During most of my career as a clinician, I looked askance at other doctors who displayed in their reception rooms testimonial letters from satisfied patients. I thought this method that some doctors used to promote their practices gave an imbalanced view of the doctors' abilities. "Well," I thought, "these patients (the ones who've written the testimonial letters) are satisfied with the doctors' abilities. But what about patients who aren't satisfied. Is it fair," I asked, "to display letters from satisfied patients but not from dissatisfied ones?"

With the advent of the Internetand communications with hundreds of patientsI learned an important lesson: Word-of-mouth reporting of experiences with doctors and treatments is obviously of great interest to patients. In fact, many patients value credible opinions of other patients far more than they do those of doctors. I've even found some newsgroups where the opinions of patients are welcome but those of doctors aren't. Because so many patients value testimonials from other patients, we now provide this testimonial page on drlowe.com.

I still, however, believe that testimonials give an unbalanced view in that they're always positive. Because of this, I caution readers to look at every type of evidence possible—not just testimonials from satisfied patients—in deciding whether a treatment is right for them. I advise, for example, that patients evaluate the scientific evidence for the effectiveness and safety of a treatment praised in patients' testimonials. 

We'll publish here select letters by those who agree to share them so that others might benefit from their personal experiences. —Dr. John C. Lowe (August 27, 2002)


We often hear from people who remained ill on T4-replacement who then fully recovered after switching to thyroid hormone products that contained both T4 and T3. Below is a well-expressed example. It's from a writer, Torry Meeks, who improved slightly on Synthroid but then fully recovered after switching to Armour.

Subj: Thank You
Date:10/18/2005
From: Torrey Meeks
To: askdrlowe@drlowe.com

Dr. Lowe,

We've never met or exchanged e-mails, so you don't know me. I also understand that you're a very busy man and may not have time to respond to me. I just wanted to send you a note of thanks for your comprehensive website on metabolic health. Two years ago I found myself, at the age of 20 after serving in the military, plagued with a variety of problems, decreasing energy, and some very troubling and seemingly disconnected health issues. I was rapidly losing weight and my hair started falling out. Within a year I was close to incapacitated and could barely get out of bed, with the only verifiable thing wrong with me according to standard medical practice being a 7.2 TSH level that took a year to discover, and progressively worse ideopathic anemia. I began doing extensive research, put myself on a natural health regime, and went on Synthroid, which helped only enough to allow me to move around the house most of the day. I was still only at 60% of what I had been before, with a limited ability to concentrate, poor eyesight, and a very weak heart that limited the amount of exercise I could do, though I still did every day.

At some point in my research I stumbled across your website, gobbled up all the information you had readily available, and was seduced by the exceeding logic, careful language, and excellent documentation with which you make all of your statements and hypotheses. After changing from Synthroid to Armour thyroid, exercising to tolerance, and modifying my diet, I have arrived at a place I never thought possible while at my worst. Today, a year later, I am back on my feet, in a state of good health, happily married, and, after going through two challenging jobs to prove to myself that I am still capable of living to the fullest—as a long haul truck driver, and then stone mason—I am now a full time freelance writer. Thank you very much for your sound advice and all the work you put into helping people become whole again.

Sincerely,
Torrey Meeks
Freelance Writer

The letter below is from a patient of Dr. Gina Honeyman-Lowe's. Like most of our patients, Barbara lives in another state and has continued metabolic rehab with her local doctor after Dr. Gina guided her through the initial stages of rehab. Barbara wrote in response to my critique of the four recent studies of thyroid hormone replacement therapies. After expressing her outrage at the close minds within the medical community, she describes her remarkable improvement after switching from Synthroid to T3. We want to emphasize that most hypothyroid patients recover by using products that contain both T4 and T3, such as Armour and Thyrolar. Some patients, however, recover only when they use plain (not sustained-release) T3. Barbara is an excellent example of such patients. —JCL

Subj: comments on the critique in your recent newsletter
Date: 6/8/2004 4:40:25 PM Mountain Daylight Time
From: Barbara Harms
To: MetabolicHealth@aol.com

Dear Dr. Gina,

I haven't written in a while because I have been feeling so much better. I just read in your newsletter about the 4 studies recently done and the conclusions that were drawn. I am outraged at the closed minds which are so prevalent in the medical community. I would be happy for you to use my successful history of metabolic rehab if it would help in any way to provide further evidence that T4-replacement keeps some patients ill. 

I was diagnosed as hypothyroid many years ago, as you may recall, with all the symptoms full blowndespite my being on Synthroid for years. It had reached the point where I had massive weight gains, 100+ pounds, and could not stop the continuing weight gain no matter what I did. I also had full blown fibromyalgia. 

I owe my life in many ways to you and Dr. Lowe. Today, on 137 mcg of T3, I am 90% symptom free. I have finally stopped gaining weight and can actually lose weight! I am working on that at present. You have given me my life backI can move and go places and do things which had become almost impossible to do. I had been forced to the point of needing a wheelchair if I was to go where walking was involved. Just a simple thing like going to the mall was impossible for me. 

Things are so different for me now and it's all thanks to you, without a doubt. We are actually going to England in 2 weeks, a thing I never dreamed would be possible before your help! Thank you again & again.

Sincerely,
Barbara Harms

The letter below is from a chiropractic physician. With little long-distance guidance by Dr. Gina Honeyman-Lowe, he has remarkably improved his wife's fibromyalgia. Helping loved ones improve or recover through metabolic rehab is the way some doctors learn to treat fibromyalgia patients effectively. We encourage patients to seek out such doctors for treatment. —JCL 

Subj: Wife’s improved health
Date: 6/11/2003 4:20:19 PM Mountain Daylight Time
From: Dr. Thomas E. Schreppler
To: DrHoneymanLowe@aol.com

Dear Dr. Gina:

I am a chiropractor whom you’ve helped immensely in the past with my wife's care for her fibromyalgia. She is doing extremely well at 112.5 mcg of T3 per day, single-dose.

Quite frankly, I’m amazed. Prior to institution of your protocol, in addition to nighttime sleep, she was for all purposes bedridden 5 hours per day. She was in bed from late morning till late afternoon when she recouped enough strength to finish the day at 7-to-8 PM. Her migraines were debilitating at a frequency of perhaps 6-to-8 per month. The slightest or most mundane chores or activities aggravated her areas of fibromyalgia pain. Her medial plantar arches were painful with even minimal walking.

Introduction of your treatment regimen produced no relief until we titrated up her dose at weekly intervals to her current dose. She could go no higher without heart palpitations and other signs of toxicity. She stayed at this dose for about 4-to-6 weeks before she could identify consistent, discernable relief. Another 3-to-4 months progressed with continued improvement which gave us confidence that she would continue to improve. Now, 2 years after introduction of care, I’m happy to report that she has 80%-to-90% relief from her muscular symptoms, and dramatic reduction in her fatigue without need for daytime recumbent rest. Her headache frequency has decreased to perhaps 2-to-3 migraines per month and sometimes even less.

I’m grateful for both your and your husband's research and clinical expertise. How better to say this: God Bless You Both.

Thank you,
Dr. Thomas E. Schreppler

The letter below is from a person who used information from our website to overcome her hypothyroid symptoms. Her experience shows something important: While most patients fair best by using a preparation containing both T4 and T3, some patients benefit from the use of T4 alone if the dose is high enough. Patients and doctors should bear in mind that before endocrinologists imposed the tyranny of the TSH on hypothyroid patients, most patients took far higher doses of thyroid hormone. In stark contrast to the teensy doses conventional doctors use today, the higher doses were both safe and effective. The patient's letter below shows the benefits of higher doses. —JCL
 
Subj: Alicia Johnson
Date: 12/31/2002 5:51:27 PM Mountain Standard Time
To: MetabolicHealth@aol.com

Dear Dr. Lowe,

You've changed my life. It all began when I was diagnosed with hyperthyroidism. I decided to be treated with radioactive iodine. After I had my thyroid burned out, I began being treated with 50 mcg of T4.

It had me so ill! I remember telling my doctor during so many visits how seriously ill I still felt even with treatment, listing all the symptoms of hypothyroidism. She would reply that my TSH level was normal, so it's not related. For so long, I thought I had some type of incurable disease.

With your help and versatile and intellectual approach to understanding thyroid problems, I’m now better. Your theory of T4 and metabolic health is literal, precise, and accurate. Too low of dosage is what was keeping me ill with symptoms of hypothyroidism. With a higher dosage of 200 mcg and a doctor who is understanding, patient, and willing to try different medicines, my metabolism is now normal and I feel better again. Now I can start school, which I had been so reluctant about because I was so ill. I feel as If I've wasted precious time dealing with so many uncompassionate and uncaring doctors. 

Alicia Johnson

The letter below illustrates something for which I'm extreme proud: that my book The Metabolic Treatment of Fibromyalgia has enabled many patients to finally get effective treatment for their fibromyalgia symptoms underlain by thyroid problems. —JCL

Subj: Thank You!!
Date: 8/23/2002 10:17:08 AM Mountain Daylight Time
From: magnoliac51@hotmail.com (Cheryl Hamilton, RN)
To: DrJohnLowe@aol.com

Dr. Lowe,

After 5 years of extreme fatigue, poor mentation, muscle aches, terrible eczema, sleep apnea, etc., I had to quit my R.N. hospital position after 30 years of nursing. I was so sick I thought I was dying. But thanks to you I am doing much better and expect a full recovery.

When the symptoms first appeared I was diagnosed with hypothyroidism. But when I showed no improvement after 6 weeks on 100 mcg Synthroid and my TSH was in the "normal range", I was referred to other doctors. It was the typical experience you write about. I was diagnosed with fibromyalgia and of course advised that my continued weight gain and lack of exercise was the problem. Typically, I was offered antidepressants because there had to be psychological problems I was failing to address. I just kept getting worse no matter how hard I tried to exercise (which was a Herculean effort) and lose weight. I became "thoughtless" (so dumb I had no thoughts) and fat (50lbs gained), and struggled daily to do simple activities. I spoke strangely—slowly with strange word combinations. Luckily I had great support from family and friends who remembered I once had been energetic, fun, and smart.

I kept looking for answers and refused all the narcotics and antidepressants offered because I knew something real was wrong with me and it wasn't "in my head". There was no chaos in my life except my illness. Then I read your book The Metabolic Treatment of Fibromyalgia and had planned to visit you, but found a local endocrinologist (surprise) that actually treats the patient and not the labs. He prescribes Cytomel. The education I received from your book and website helped me evaluate this endocrinologist. Thank you for giving me back my life. And many thanks to you assistant Gail Arnold for giving me two of your patients' email addresses so that I could get advice. I am taking the supplements you recommend, walking now 1˝ miles daily, and have lost 14 lbs. This great improvement with just adding 20 mcg of Cytomel. How simple.

Your book continues to be my best resource. Thanks so much. May great blessings come your way.

Sincerely,
Cheryl Hamilton, RN